| Year | Name | Sport | State Induction |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1992 | Robert Ford | Basketball | |
| 1992 | John Pincavage | Football | |
| 1992 | Troy Snyder | Soccer | |
| 1992 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 1993 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 1993 | Al Harnly | Football | |
| 1993 | Walter “Buddy” Heckman | Golf | |
| 1993 | Robert “Cotton” Hirneisen | Golf | |
| 1993 | Bob Mitzel | All Around | |
| 1993 | Terry Reber | All Around | |
| 1993 | Bill Remley | Soccer | |
| 1993 | Gary Distasio | Softball | |
| 1993 | Joan Gruber | Ice Skating | |
| 1993 | Kris Bankes Jacoby | Track & Field | |
| 1993 | Gary Walters | Basketball | |
| 1994 | Gina Stallone Amrich | Gymnastics | |
| 1994 | Joseph Consoli | Baseball | |
| 1994 | George Eyrich | Baseball | |
| 1994 | Art Heffner | All Around | |
| 1994 | J. Elmer “Buddy” Lutz | Golf | |
| 1994 | Tommy Miller | Football | |
| 1994 | Mike Raszkiewicz | Handball | |
| 1994 | Lester “Epp” Sell | Baseball | |
| 1994 | Lee Hill | All Around | |
| 1994 | Steve Rossignoli | Basketball | |
| 1994 | Reggie Weiss | Basketball | |
| 1994 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 1995 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 1995 | Harvey E. Bachert, Sr. | All Around | |
| 1995 | Lewis Bertsch | Baseball | |
| 1995 | Amedeo “Dick” DeAngelis | Football | |
| 1995 | Harold “Jazz” Kase | All Around | |
| 1995 | James Mikus | Gymnastics | |
| 1995 | Robert Rentschler | Baseball | |
| 1995 | Don Thomas | Football | 2000 |
| 1995 | Richard Trexler | Basketball | |
| 1995 | Kathy Frey | Bowling | |
| 1995 | Gerry Slemmer | Football | |
| 1995 | John Stopper | Football | |
| 1996 | Barry Boyer | All Around | |
| 1996 | Joel Arnold III | Tennis | |
| 1996 | Arlan Baver | All Around | |
| 1996 | Helen Sokol Ciabattoni | Swimming | |
| 1996 | Mike Kemp | All Around | |
| 1996 | Richard Knoblauch | Baseball | |
| 1996 | Paul S. Limpus, Jr. | Bowling | |
| 1996 | John Szajna | All Around | |
| 1996 | Charles “Babe” Tulley | All Around | |
| 1996 | Edward Jablonski | All Around | |
| 1996 | Dennis Westley | Basketball | |
| Year | Name | Sport | State Induction |
