| Year | Name | Sport | State Induction |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 2010 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 2013 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 2014 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 2017 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 2018 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 2026 | Kerry Ciatto | Adminstrator | |
| 2026 | Julie Pelchar Cohen | Golf | |
| 2026 | Derek Sola | Wrestling | |
| 2026 | Matt Coldren | Basketball | |
| 2026 | Mel Edwards | Baseball - Basketball | |
| 2026 | Tom Houck | Swimming Water Polo | |
| 2026 | Chris Lea | All Around | |
| 2026 | Recipients - Special Awards | Distinguished Award | |
| 1976 | Bill Horine | Basketball | |
| 1976 | William "Bill" Reedy | Sports Writer | |
| 1977 | Charles Dunkelberger | Baseball | |
| 1977 | Mavin “Mercer” Gehman | Wrestling | |
| 1977 | Abe Goodman | Basketball | |
| 1977 | Emmanuel “Manny” Jacobs | Administrator - Coach | |
| 1978 | Lloyd “Scoop” Clemens | Coaching | |
| 1978 | Dominic Dallessandro | Baseball | |
| 1978 | Johnny Dietrich | Basketball | |
| 1978 | Betty Fehl Fegely | Golf | |
| 1978 | George “Horse” Haggerty | Basketball | |
| 1978 | Stewart “Spike” Moyer | Soccer | |
| 1978 | William “Woozy” Smith | Basketball Official | |
| 1978 | Pete Yousaitis | Basketball | |
| 1979 | William Firing | Track & Field | |
| 1979 | Hoby Geesaman | Sports Medicine | |
| 1979 | Jack Hemmig | Administrator - Coach | |
| 1979 | Bob Perugini | Football | |
| 1979 | John Smith | Basketball | |
| 1980 | Norbert “Yummy” Billinger | Football | |
| 1980 | Rocky Colavito | Baseball | |
| 1980 | Samuel Goodman | Basketball | |
| 1980 | Robert E. Kerper, Jr | Swimming | |
| 1980 | Dr. Ralph Mulligan | Coaching | |
| 1980 | Jimmy Oslislo | Basketball | |
| 1980 | Harry Polter | Basketball | |
| 1980 | Dr. Wilbur G. Renken | Basketball | |
| 1980 | Eugene L. Shirk | Track & Field | |
| 1980 | Chuck Thompson | Media | |
| 1981 | Harry “Yummy” Armpriester | Basketball | |
| 1981 | Ed Cammarota | Football | |
| 1981 | Dr. Karl Friedman | Basketball | |
| 1981 | Max Missbach, Sr. | Baseball | |
| 1981 | Bobby Rothenberger | Baseball | |
| 1981 | John Shaner | Track & Field | |
| 1981 | Dr. Edward Twardowski | Swimming | |
| Year | Name | Sport | State Induction |
